Smrt Lernins

Smrt Lernins

One Mother's Homeschool Education

  • Home
  • Smrt Mama’s Adventures in Smrt Lernins
  • Secular Thursday
  • Smrt Curricula

DK Books and the Smrt Mama who loves them

Posted in History sure is...interesting, Homeschoolins, NaBloPoMo, Smrt Book/Curricula Reviews by Smrt Mama
Nov 11 2009
TrackBack Address.

As a secular homeschooler, I have a deep fondness for DK Publishing. I wasn’t interested in purchasing a boxed history curriculum, even if one I felt was both adequately rigorous and completely secular were available to me. Instead, I chose to pick a main text for developing a timeline and use supporting texts and other resources (websites, field trips, fiction stories, mythology trivia cards, etc.) to supplement. The books from DK Publishing have largely filled that need.

Here are a few DK texts we’ve used so far this year:

History: The Definitive Visual Guide provides the spine for our history curriculum. This book uses secular dating (BCE/CE) and doesn’t couch history in terms of religious events. As the title suggests, this text is visually stunning, with full color pictures of settings, people, and artifacts. Each section starts with a timeline of important events. The chapters are fairly information-dense, which makes this book appropriate for strong readers of the logic stage and up. The book does leave some gaps in knowledge. Overall cultural accomplishments are well covered, but many important events and people receive too small a mention. For example, Ancient Greece, I couldn’t find a single reference to the Battle of Thermopylae. Make sure you read through each section and choose appropriate supplemental materials for the thin areas. On the whole, however, it’s a much deeper look into each time period than any other history book I considered for our spine — it beats the singularly nonsecular Kingfisher history hands-down and is better than the Usborne for an older student.

The Eyewitness series is one of our best sources of supplemental reading. Thus far, we’ve used Eyewitness: Mesopotamia, Eyewitness: Ancient Greece, and are beginning Eyewitness: Ancient Rome. These books provide detailed information about the arts, technologies, daily life, clothing, and other cultural aspects of each time period. They, too, have many wonderful illustrations with detailed captions and each has a pull out full-color poster with important terms, events, people, and other details. We like to put our posters up right by Captain Science’s workspace. They also come with clip-art CDs, which we haven’t used, but might in the future. I have to say, both Eyewitness: Mesopotamia and Eyewitness: Ancient Greece contained more information than I remember learning about either culture until at least high school, and possible college, in the case of Mesopotamia. The books are written for children around age 8+, so it’s easy for children to engage with the material, but it’s by no means dumbed-down or overly simplistic. The biggest down side of using these as a school text was that Captain Science would sneak off with them and read them straight through instead of waiting on each lesson.

Many of the sections in the Eyewitness books match up well topically with History: The Definitive Visual Guide. When we covered Alexander the Great, Captain Science read the sections in both books, which presented the information in two slightly different ways and presented a nicely rounded picture of this famous ruler. The sections on science and medicine in both books matched up nicely, too. I’m looking forward to seeing if Eyewitness: Ancient Rome and the chapters in History have the same degree of parity.

All in all, you can consider this post my love letter to DK Publishing, because I’ve been very pleased with everything I’ve purchased so far. Even better, because these aren’t books aren’t published specifically for homeschoolers, I’ve been able to find them in my local book stores and use coupons and my educator discounts on them! Nothing like inexpensive, secular, quality texts to make a history-loving homeschooler a happy mama!

Tagged as: dk publishing, NaBloPoMo, secular curriculum
Comments
  • Daisy:

    Great idea! I’m going to look into these to supplement our ancients curriculum. I’m sure our library probably has them.

    Reply November 11, 2009 at 9:19 PM
  • Julia:

    Kingfisher isn’t secular? I don’t have a copy yet, but I assumed it was. I was planning to get it next year.

    Reply November 12, 2009 at 9:33 AM
    • Smrt Mama:

      I didn’t find it secular. It gives dates in BC/AD and the chapter on the Hebrews was way more “God’s chosen people!!!” than it was about their history, IMO.

      Reply November 12, 2009 at 10:21 AM
  • Care:

    Yes, I’m terribly current, aren’t I?

    9.9;;

    Anyhow. I was wondering about your thoughts on the DK Publishing materials versus the Very Recommended (in the book, anyhow) Story of the World. Yes, I’m also going right out to investigate myself, but I figure if I know and trust your opinions, I’d like to ask them. Particularly if there’s even a slight chance you’ve seen both sets of materials, and can give a reasonable opinion…. and leave me not having to buy both to sort out what opinions I can trust. o.o;;;

    Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:19 PM
    • Smrt Mama:

      Well, Story of the World isn’t remotely secular. It’s very Judeo-Christian-centric. The most recent edition is apparently not as bad, but it’s still not secular.

      Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:23 PM
      • Care:

        Well, I suppose that was easy enough. o.O;; I didn’t even have time to go look – I posted, I changed a diaper, there’s a reply. o.o;;

        I suppose this means that all things recommended in WTM are probably in a dire need of vetting for secular-ity before purchase. Why do you suppose the book, which seems written from a religious-but-trying-to-be-secular viewpoint, doesn’t point these things out?

        Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:35 PM
        • Smrt Mama:

          I do think they’re pretty on the level about their degree of non-secularity. Some of the recommendations do need to be vetted, but mostly they’re ok.

          Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:39 PM
          • Care:

            It’s also very possible that I just missed the part where they pointed it out – I’ve been reading in chunks recently. XD

            I’ll keep an eye out. ^_^ Thank you for the tip!

            (Yes, I know I’m looking entirely too early. But I figure if I can get a good idea of what I’d like to start with, then I can slowly accumulate, and by the time he’s ready to start school, it won’t be five thousand things we need to buy all at once)

            Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:51 PM
            • Smrt Mama:

              Hey, early planning is good!

              Reply May 30, 2010 at 1:55 PM
              • Care:

                Honestly, I’m hoping that in addition to defraying the initial “start-up” cost, that planning will also keep me occupied enough to be patient and not go rushing out to buy whatever it is I’ve heard about and start *tomorrow.* I know my little isn’t old enough for school yet, and there are still many things he needs to know before he is. I’m just very twitchy (particularly with Girl Next Door trotting off to preschool every day) to be doing something. XD So I’m trying to distract myself and keep the “teaching” to developmentally appropriate stuff. XD

                Reply May 30, 2010 at 2:03 PM
                • Smrt Mama:

                  Yes, I haven’t yet had the “everyone else is going to preschool, but my baby is staying home” experience. I’ll have that w/ Babypie, though.

                  Reply May 30, 2010 at 2:04 PM
                  • Care:

                    Yeah. I already get a lot of weird looks because LP isn’t in a “preschool” program. I know full well it’s a big daycare at not-quite-two, but it’s still weird. Like I’m stunting his intellectual growth by keeping him home to play with Duplos instead of sending him to a bigger building to do play Duplos with other kids. o.o;;

                    Okay. And just to submit a new “Ask a [Smrt] Homeschooler” question: What do you think regarding using the library for materials? Is it worth going out and buying your own copy of all materials? Will the library (be likely to) have core texts and you can just use all their books? Is a blend a reasonable and feasible option?

                    Reply May 30, 2010 at 2:13 PM
                    • Smrt Mama:

                      That’s a good question! Can it wait until Tuesday and be my featured question?

                      May 30, 2010 at 2:15 PM
                    • Care:

                      Odd, I can’t reply to your reply. o.o; Apparently, I’m too chatty. So I reply here.

                      And absolutely it can wait until Tuesday. ^_^ I’m not going to be able to buy between now and then, and I sure as hell can’t borrow from the library and keep the book for the next three to five years. XD

                      May 30, 2010 at 2:20 PM
Leave a Comment
Click here to cancel reply.

Calendar of Lernins

November 2009
S M T W T F S
« Oct   Dec »
 1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  
Subscribe

Past Lernins

  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009












Homeschool Buyers Co-op
Homeschooling's
#1 Way to Save

Lernins Categories

  • 101 in 1001
  • Babypie
  • Blogging About Blogging
  • Dawdling Days
  • Earnest Mom is Earnest
  • Eff Off Friday
  • Funny Lernins
  • homeschoolin: ur doin it wrong
  • Homeschoolins
    • Artistic Lernins
    • Ask a [Smrt] Homeschooler
    • History sure is…interesting
    • Lab Lernins
    • Lernins On the Go
    • Secular Homeschooling Archetypes
    • Secular Lernins
      • Secular Thursdays
    • Smrt Curriculum
    • Table Lernins
    • Weekly Rewiewins
  • Maybe don't let your kids read this
  • My Kid Impresses Me
  • NaBloPoMo
  • Peace Begins at Home
  • Smrt Book/Curricula Reviews
  • Smrt Lernins Contest
  • Smrt Mama
  • Smrt Parenting Stuff
  • Smrt Products
  • Smrt Stuff to Share
  • Smrt Thinkins
  • The Slappening
  • The Tank
  • Wordless Wednesday

The McLernins

Blogroll

  • A Little Rebellion
  • Classless and Lovin' It
  • Concordia Classical Academy
  • Doc's Sunrise Rants
  • Elemental Science
  • Four Squares
  • Grassroots Homeschool
  • Heathen Homeschoolers
  • Lucy & Ethel Have a Baby
  • Satori Smiles
  • The Diosa Dotada Endeavor
Powered by WordPress | “Blend” from Spectacu.la WP Themes Club